27 New Road, Bromsgrove, Worcestershire B60 2JLBromsgrove, Worcestershire01527 919848
Droitwich Knee & Shoulder ClinicPatient guides · Since 1988
Patient guide · Knee treatment options

Physiotherapy, injections or knee replacement?

These options do different jobs. Understand what each one is for, where its limits are and which questions to take into your consultation.

Under clinical reviewThis guide is being reviewed by Mr Moholkar. It is general information, not a personal treatment recommendation.

01Diagnosis before procedureThe cause of your symptoms shapes the reasonable choices.
02Function mattersPain, sleep, walking, work and your goals all count.
03Decide togetherAsk about benefits, limits, risks, recovery and costs.
At a glance

Compare the purpose, not just the procedure.

This table focuses on knee osteoarthritis because the guidance differs from other knee conditions. Your clinician should explain which options apply to your diagnosis.

A general comparison to help you prepare questions. It does not tell you which treatment to choose.
OptionMain purposeWhen it may be discussedImportant limits
Physiotherapy and therapeutic exerciseBuild strength, movement and confidence with an exercise plan suited to your knee and daily life.For many knee conditions, including osteoarthritis and rehabilitation after injury. NICE describes therapeutic exercise as a core treatment for osteoarthritis.It needs regular participation. The plan should be reviewed if it is not helping or your symptoms worsen.
Steroid injectionReduce pain and swelling inside the knee joint for short-term relief.For osteoarthritis when other medicines are ineffective or unsuitable, or to support therapeutic exercise. Suitability depends on your health and diagnosis.Relief is temporary. An injection does not reverse arthritis or replace exercise and rehabilitation when those are needed.
Knee replacementReplace damaged joint surfaces with artificial parts, with the aim of reducing pain and improving function.When symptoms substantially affect quality of life and non-surgical management has not helped or is unsuitable.It is an operation with risks and a rehabilitation period. The expected benefit and type of replacement depend on your individual assessment.

Other options, such as pain relief, activity changes and walking aids, may also form part of the discussion. Not all knee pain is caused by osteoarthritis, and this table does not cover every diagnosis or procedure.

A better decision

Start with your knee, not a treatment menu.

A consultation should narrow down the choices that make sense for you. These three steps keep the discussion grounded.

  1. Confirm what is causing the problem

    Your history and examination come first. Existing letters and scan reports can add useful context. Further imaging is only useful when it answers a relevant question.

  2. Describe what the symptoms stop you doing

    Talk about sleep, walking, stairs, work, sport and the activities you want to return to. The effect on your life is more useful than trying to rate your pain out of ten alone.

  3. Compare every reasonable choice

    Ask what happens if you wait, which non-surgical options remain, and what each treatment involves. Include the likely benefit, important risks, recovery, costs and alternatives.

Take these with you

Six questions worth asking.

You do not need to remember every medical term. A written list helps you leave with answers that matter to your decision.

  1. What do you think is causing my knee symptoms?
  2. What are the reasonable alternatives for me, including no immediate treatment?
  3. What benefit can I realistically expect, and what are the main risks?
  4. How will this affect exercise, work and everyday activities?
  5. What rehabilitation or follow-up will I need?
  6. What is included in the price, and what could cost extra?
What about keyhole surgery?

Arthroscopy is not a universal alternative.

NICE advises against arthroscopic lavage or debridement as a treatment for osteoarthritis. That is specific guidance for those procedures and that diagnosis.

It does not mean every knee arthroscopy is inappropriate. Other diagnosed problems may need a different surgical assessment. Ask what diagnosis the operation is intended to treat and why it is being recommended.

Read the NICE recommendation (opens in new tab)

Discuss your own knee

Take your questions into a consultation.

Tell the practice what is troubling you and what you want to get back to doing. Your first step is an assessment, not a commitment to treatment.

01527 919848

Need urgent medical help? This is a planned-care service and cannot provide emergency care. Call 999 or go to A&E in an emergency. For same-day medical advice, contact NHS 111 (opens in new tab).